NCAA Division III All-Americans from California
| YEAR | WEIGHT | WRESTLER | COLLEGE | HIGH SCHOOL | SECTION | PLACE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 285 | Darryl Aiello | University of Dubuque | De La Salle | NC | 4th Place |
| 2021 | 157 | Daniel Ruiz | Loras College | Madera HS | CS | 7th Place |
| 2019 | 133 | Taylor 'Kimo' Dial | US Merchant Marine Academy | Poway | SD | 8th Place |
| 2018 | 125 | CJ Pestano | Central Iowa | Torrance HS | S | 6th Place |
| 2017 | 125 | CJ Pestano | Central Iowa | Torrance HS | S | 4th Place |
| 2017 | 125 | Arnulfo Olea | Wartburg College | Exeter HS | CS | 6th Place |
| 2017 | 133 | Nathan Pike | New York University | Diamond Bar HS | S | NATIONAL CHAMPION |
| 2016 | 125 | CJ Pestano | Central Iowa | Torrance HS | S | 2nd Place |
| 2016 | 125 | Arnulfo Olea | Wartburg College | Exeter HS | CS | 5th Place |
| 2016 | 133 | Nathan Pike | New York University | Diamond Bar HS | S | 2nd Place |
| 2016 | 165 | Colin Navickas | Stevens Institute of Tech. | Marina HS | S | 4th Place |
| 2015 | 133 | Nathan Pike | New York University | Diamond Bar HS | S | 6th Place |
| 2014 | 125 | Gilberto Camacho | Wartburg College | Washington Union HS | CS | 5th Place |
| 2013 | 125 | Gilberto Camacho | Wartburg College | Washington Union HS | CS | 3rd Place |
| 2013 | 149 | Vincent Pisani | York College-PA | El Modena HS | S | 4th Place |
| 2011 | 184 | Seth Rehn | Coe College | Vista HS | SD | 5th Place |
| 2010 | 174 | Seth Rehn | Coe College | Vista HS | SD | 7th Place |
| 2008 | 285 | Glenn Geesman | Mass. Institute of Tech | Aptos HS | CC | 3rd Place |
| 2002 | 133 | Steve Martin | Loras College | Archbishop Riordan | CC | 2nd Place |
| 1997 | 118 | Jerry Boland | Lycoming College | Amador Valley HS | NC | 5th Place |
| 1981 | 158 | Vertis Elmore | CS Stanislaus | Fremont-Oakland | O | 2nd Place |
| 1980 | 118 | Marty Nellis | Humboldt State | Poway HS | SD | 3rd Place |
| 1980 | 118 | Dan Tafoya | CS Stanislaus | Ventura HS | S | 6th Place |
| 1980 | 126 | Steve Zehnder | Humboldt State | Elk Grove HS | SJ | 6th Place |
| 1980 | 142 | Mike Fredenburg | Humboldt State | Campbell HS | CC | NATIONAL CHAMPION |
| 1980 | 150 | Marty Hozela | Humboldt State | 4th Place | ||
| 1980 | 158 | Adrian Smedley | Humboldt State | Elk Grove HS | SJ | 3rd Place |
| 1980 | 167 | Rod Coudright | Humboldt State | 8th Place | ||
| 1980 | 177 | Richard Sykes | Humboldt State | Hogan HS | SJ | 5th Place |
| 1980 | 190 | Mike Malkovich | Humboldt State | Pittsburg HS | NC | 5th Place |
| 1979 | 118 | Marty Nellis | Humboldt State | Poway HS | SD | 6th Place |
| 1979 | 142 | Mike Fredenburg | Humboldt State | Campbell HS | CC | 2nd Place |
| 1979 | 142 | Brad Keith | CS Stanislaus | 5th Place | ||
| 1979 | 150 | Jon Sylvia | Humboldt State | Eureka HS | NC | 2nd Place |
| 1979 | 150 | John Parreria | CS Stanislaus | Modesto JC | 8th Place | |
| 1978 | 118 | George White | Humboldt State | 4th Place | ||
| 1978 | 158 | Tom Pender | Humboldt State | Lincoln HS | CC | 4th Place |
| 1978 | 177 | Wayne Nickerson | Humboldt State | San Dieguito HS | SD | 2nd Place |
| 1978 | 190 | Eric Woosley | Humboldt State | Arcata HS | NC | NATIONAL CHAMPION |
| 1977 | 142 | Jim Luster | Humboldt State | 2nd Place | ||
| 1977 | 150 | Mike Harr | Humboldt State | Lower Lake HS | NC | 4th Place |
| 1977 | 158 | Mike Karges | Humboldt State | Orange Glen HS | SD | 2nd Place |
| 1977 | 167 | Kris Henry | Humboldt State | Cupertino HS | CC | 2nd Place |
| 1977 | 190 | Eric Woosley | Humboldt State | Arcata HS | NC | NATIONAL CHAMPION |
| 1976 | 134 | Mel Harris | CS Stanislaus | Merced HS | SJ | 4th Place |
| 1976 | 158 | Mike Karges | Humboldt State | Orange Glen HS | SD | 6th Place |
| 1976 | 167 | Kris Henry | Humboldt State | Cupertino HS | CC | 4th Place |
| 1975 | 118 | Dwight Miller | Humboldt State | Gunn HS | CC | 4th Place |
| 1975 | 190 | Brent Wissenback | Humboldt State | Truckee HS | SJ | NATIONAL CHAMPION |